Authority
Updated: 35 minutes ago

What is it good for?
Just as in Greco-Roman times, contemporary patriarchal, cultures fetishise male physicality as a foundational source of authority. A physical projection, of desire, that reveals a dilemma. When is it helpful to grant other people authority over us and which other people? As the psychiatrist Irvin Yalom observed :
"The human being either asserts autonomy by heroic self-assertion or seeks safety through fusing with a superior force ... one either emerges or merges, separates or embeds. One becomes one’s own parent or remains the eternal child."
This blog occupies the ground between these possibilities. It will explore what granting authority is good for, when that fails, and how we might blend external authoritative structures with, a chosen, internal authority.
Power vs. authority
To understand authority, we must first isolate it from power. Power is the asymmetric control of valued social resources and the capacity to influence or control others. Power exists independently of its legitimacy. Authority is the legitimisation of that power. Authority requires 'due process.' Procedures that make power acceptable, justifiable, and normative. As established in legal frameworks, like the United States constitution, power exercised without due process is arbitrary, not authoritative.
Ultimately, however, it is individual decisions, conscious and unconscious, which legitimise power. Each of us possesses the psychological agency to grant, or strip, the authority away from the power others have over us. Philosopher Albert Camus (1961) framed this reclamation as the useful transition from the absurd to rebellion. Summating :
"the aim of a life can only be to increase the sum of freedom and responsibility to be found in everyone and in the world."
A psychological journey of evaluating and dismantling arbitrary external, and internal, controls. But what to grant, and what to strip of, it's authority at the end of such a process?
When is authority helpful?
Our initial intersection with authority begins in infancy. When a child lacks capacity, skill, and knowledge, authority is a psychological necessity. Adam Phillips (2013) describes this containment :
“ [Granting] authority is a solution to frustration - a way of managing it, a way of bearing it, a way of stopping it turning into murder or suicide or torture ... the [authoritative] parent can stay with the child with a view to containing him: stopping him harming himself, stopping him doing too much damage, but not trying to stop him having the tantrum.”
Beyond childhood containment, granting authority can have other benefits :
Shared Responsibility : Granting authority distributes the cognitive burden of system management. For example, it facilitates the efficient specialisation of tasks most suited to particularly skilled individuals. Practically building a sense of enlightened self interest to living in community with others.
Conflict Resolution : Granting people authority provides a means of arbitration in disputes, securing justice and sometimes the absence of war. It can also help strengthen attachments from which individuals and communities can grow. Not everything is constantly helpfully contested. Holding some things constant paradoxically allows a more thorough examination of some others.
Minority influence : Minorities can helpfully develop culture by widening the Overton window : The range of ideas, policies, and political arguments that the mainstream public finds acceptable at any given time. Minorities do this by being granted the authority to expose a culture to new ideas. Prompting intrigue and a desire to understand; deep processing of the minorities position; allowing public rejection and private acceptance. So facilitating a latent and private cultural influence wider than previously possible (Smith & Haslam, 2026.)
Self-efficacy & control : Granting authority can help individuals can cultivate a predictable internal locus of control i.e. the belief that you, through your own actions, choices, and effort, directly influence the outcomes and events in your life. A successful maturation according to developmental models (Maier, 2025.) They suggest authority progresses through a three-stage trajectory. From externally derived authority to internally derived authority. Partially in recognition of when granting authority to others is unhelpful.
When is authority unhelpful?
The hazards of misplaced authority are severe. Authority frequently operates through splitting and othering. It can force individuals into rigid, reciprocal relational roles (e.g. controlling vs. controlled, judging vs. judged.) This hierarchy can degenerate into a license for violence or an absolute demand for silence. As visible in criminal cultures of omertà (mafia-style structures.) These are the traps of systemic control.
Invisible subjugation : As Fyodor Dostoevsky noted, "The best way to keep a prisoner from escaping is to make sure he never knows he's in prison." So systems often conceal their power rather than risk being subject to challenge.
The spectacle of rank : We can respect the rank instead of the person i.e. acting as if the naked emperor is still wearing clothes. As George Eliot wrote in Middlemarch, "There is a pale shade of bribery which is sometimes called prosperity." Illustrating how we may give authority to those in power in order to gain access to their resources. These strategies are not always in our best interests.
De-individuation : Social psychology conformity studies show that when authority is state-sanctioned, ordinary individuals can act murderously with no prior history of violence (Smith & Haslam, 2026.) As illustrated by the 'ordinary men' who carried out the holocaust by bullets in WW2 (Halmburger & Oldenburg, 2022.)
The tyranny of the monopoly : Monopolies on authority isolate ourselves, other singular figures or groups. These monopolies can then demand constant narcissistic supply i.e. attention, admiration, validation, or emotional reaction. This can become tyrannical towards others. Age too is a traditional repository of monopolised authority.
The authority shift across generations
Technological acceleration has disrupted traditional hierarchies. Baseline cultural shifts are happening rapidly. Meaning historical lived experience carries less functional capital than before. In this context, older generations have less default structural authority over the young. Paving the way for diffuse, collaborative platforms of knowledge. A space of potential co-production and mutual responsibility. Recognising shared interests without establishing hierarchies. So as the absolute need for a protective or punitive figure to look up to disappears. We can focus on looking around for both inspiration and help.
Reclaiming authority
Reclaiming authority involves moving away from viewing current authorities as entirely corrupt or always right. Transitioning from a paranoid-schizoid position towards a mature depressive position (Klein, 1952.) In the paranoid -schizoid position we hold people in rigid, all-or-nothing categories of wholly good or wholly bad with little to no integration between them. In the depressive position, the child begins to perceive the mother (and others) as whole, separate people who possess both good and bad qualities. We can then begin to recognise that both the currently governing and governed possess complex psychologies. The start of breaking symbiotic, disabling cycles of rigid reciprocal roles involving ourselves and current authorities (Perry, 2020.)
For example in clinical practice, authority is never absolute. It is a temporary, specialised role appointed to the practitioner through the patient's informed and ongoing consent. Where the client lends some of their authority to the practitioner to achieve specific ends :
Therapy interrogates the superego : Psychological treatment works to dismantle harsh internal critics, unwritten rules and implicit biases. For example therapists help interrogate the self criticism emanating from our punishing superego commands (Phillips, 2015.)
The danger of ambition : Setting ambitious goals for clients can inadvertently mirror oppressive authority. Practitioners must share responsibility to avoid stepping into victim, rescuing, or persecuting, roles (Karpman, 1968.) For example intersubjective psychotherapy gives explicit recognition of the authority held by both participants in therapy. So we can move beyond, the doer and the done to, roles in helping relationships (Benjamin, 2018; Perry, 2020.)
Summary
Authority is the psychological mechanism by which individuals and communities legitimise power. Granted flexibly it can help people, and communities, grow and develop. Granted inflexibly it can be murderous. Reclaiming our authority involves the dynamic evaluation of its utility in each situation. Trading mythical or political strongmen, like Hercules, for diffuse, creative, sources of help.
References
Benjamin, J. (2018). Beyond doer and done to: Recognition theory, intersubjectivity and the third. Routledge.
Camus, A. (1961). Resistance, rebellion, and death. Knopf.
Cisłak, A. (2022). Power: Our fundamental concept. The Psychologist, 35(11), 28–29. https://explore.bps.org.uk/content/bpsfu/1/144/20
Eliot, G. (1993). Middlemarch. Wordsworth Editions. (Original work published 1871)
Halmburger, O., & Oldenburg, M. (Directors). (2022). Ordinary Men: The "Forgotten Holocaust" [Film]. Broadview TV; Netflix. https://www.netflix.com/gb/title/81672035
Karpman, S. B. (1968). Fairy tales and script drama analysis. Transactional Analysis Bulletin, 7(26), 39–43
Klein, M. (1952). Some theoretical conclusions regarding the emotional life of the infant. In M. Klein, P. Heimann, S. Isaacs, & J. Riviere (Eds.), Developments in Psycho-Analysis (p. 236). London: Hogarth Press
Maier, D. (2025). The Architecture of Inner Authority [Blog series]. Supakind. https://www.supakind.me/blog/the-architecture-of-inner-authority-
Perry, A. (2020, July 8). New relationships. Dr Andrew Perry - Clinical Psychologist. https://www.drandrewperry.org/post/new-relationships
Perry, A. (2020, July 8). Permission to come alongside? Dr Andrew Perry - Clinical Psychologist. https://www.drandrewperry.org/post/permission-to-come-alongside-forensic
Phillips, A. (2013). The magical act of a desperate person. London Review of Books. https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v35/n05/adam-phillips/the-magical-act-of-a-desperate-person
Phillips, A. (2015, March 5). Against self-criticism. London Review of Books, 37(5), 13–16. https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v37/n05/adam-phillips/against-self-criticism
Smith, J. R., & Haslam, S. A. (Eds.). (2026). Social psychology: Revisiting the classic studies (3rd ed.). SAGE Publications.
nb. I have also collated additional resources on social psychology which help contextualise authority in culture further : CLICK HERE
.jpg)



